Let me take you down

I just learned that people are listening to music pitched slightly down because it makes them feel better. Instead of the A above middle C being set at 440 Hz, they have it tuned down to 432 Hz.

This strikes me as odd, but how you feel is how you feel. Do whatever you want, as long as it doesn’t hurt anyone. I was interested, though, in the math behind this pitch change.

In the equal-tempered scale, the frequency ratio of a semitone, which I’ll call rs is the twelfth root of two:

rs=212=21121.059463

This is the ratio of frequencies of adjacent piano keys.

The ratio of 440 Hz to 432 Hz is

440432=55541.0185185

so the pitch difference you get from moving down to 432 Hz is distinctly less than a semitone. How can we characterize that difference?

Small differences in pitch are measured in cents. There are 100 cents in a semitone, so the frequency ratio of one cent, rc, is

rc=rs100=2112001.00057779

To get the number of cents we move down in going from 440 Hz to 432 Hz, we solve this equation for n:

(211200)n=2n1200=5554

Taking the base-2 logarithm of both sides yields

n1200=log2(5554)

and therefore

n=1200log2(5554)31.767

So going from A440 tuning to A432 tuning means going down about 32 cents or about a third of a semitone. Not a lot, but you (probably) can hear it.

Here’s two seconds of A440:

And here’s two seconds of A432:

It’s easier to hear the difference when they’re played simultaneously because the beat frequency is distinct:


Given the name of this blog, I would be remiss if I didn’t mention the famous splice in “Strawberry Fields Forever.” There were two takes that John Lennon liked: a slower version in a lower key and a faster version in a higher key. He wanted the final song to have part of one and part of the other. Right. As luck would have it, though, producer George Martin and engineer Geoff Emerick learned that adjusting the tape speeds to bring the two tempos together also put them in the same key.